Recommended Practices for Fostering Inclusive Interactions
Authenticity, community guidelines, structured discussions, and "survivable risk." These are some of the strategies Shane Whalley, LMSW, uses to promote real and inclusive spaces in hir classroom in the Steve Hicks School of Social Work.
As Shane shares hir approach to fostering inclusive interactions in the classroom, think about what strategies you use to facilitate class discussions, and how you model for your students what you expect from them.
There are a variety of strategies for developing inclusive interactions among students, between students and the instructor, and harnessing the power of those interactions to build and maintain a positive classroom community. Remember that fostering an inclusive approach to learning is intentional.
Consider the many ways your students can connect with you and with each other, including their backgrounds, familiarity with the subject matter, experiences, and identities.
Click on the images below to discover strategies related to these modes of interaction. For an extended explanation of these practices, and additional recommendations, you may download thispdf version of strategiesDownload pdf version of strategies based on those outlined in the links below.
Promoting interactions between students
Have students work collaboratively to establish guidelines for class discussion.
Help students learn how to contribute to class conversation without dominating it.
Provide opportunities for the students to get to know one another throughout the semester with icebreakers and activities.
If you create groups, make sure your groups have a diverse representation of skills, experience, and identities (but do not isolate students from marginalized identities).
Inviting interactions between students and instructors
Get to know your students.
Learn and use the names and pronouns students give you.
Consistently communicate high expectations for all students.
Provide multiple ways for students to contact you if they have questions.
Make sure you are familiar with student resources on campus.
Make the learning process visible to students.
Share a little bit about yourself with students. Opening up about your own educational experiences, your hobbies, or your favorite book can help students connect with you, and can demystify the "instructor" role as something wholly "other."
Building a positive class climate and community
Make time to address student concerns about process.
Provide students with multiple opportunities to give feedback on the course climate, and be prepared to respond to that feedback.
Encourage multiple perspectives in class discussion.
When conflict arises, address it. There are many ways to address conflict, but one key principle is to maintain the class focus on the issue at hand, not an individual.
As you think about these possible approaches, also consider how might you prepare students for active learning activities? What are some ways you can encourage cooperation between students and within the class? As you reflect on this activity, are there any adjustments you may consider making in the future when incorporate active learning strategies in your classes?
Option A: Ask students to read passages of the course text out loud.
What might you consider when choosing who should read to the class? Could some students benefit from hearing the material, rather than reading it?
What may make some students feel uncomfortable in these situations? How might some students feel empowered in these situations?
Option B: Implement personal response systems (“clickers”) for quick checks for learning.
How might a student who frequently answers the questions wrong feel?
Could all of the students benefit from a break-down of the distractors (the “wrong” answers) in addition to the confirmation of the correct answer? Why or why not?
What options for getting additional support and tutoring might you offer all of the students?
Option C: Use a quick “think-pair-share” activity to encourage quieter students to participate in class discussion.
How might students with learning disabilities, English language learners, or students who are more introverted feel about their ability to process information on their own in a short amount of time?
What might you do to encourage a more diverse array of voices during the share-out stage of the activity?
As the instructor in a media and photography class, your students were asked to take photos of each other and then as a class, offer suggestions for each other's work. The class is comprised of all white students and one black student. Lindsay, who is white, photographed Marc, who is black, for this project. When Lindsay presented her work to the class, you realize you must discuss differences in photographing different skin tones. Lindsay somewhat embarrassingly stated she “didn’t know how to photograph other skin tones” and that’s why her work didn’t come out as well.
As the instructor, which of the following responses would you choose to respond to this situation?
Option A: You realize this discussion is creating an uncomfortable environment for everyone in the classroom – yourself included. You quickly skip to the next student’s work and continue with the discussion.
By choosing this option, do you think any students in this class were silenced? In what ways?
What are some strategies you may consider instead of moving the discussion to the next student’s work?
Option B: You are concerned about how uncomfortable Marc may feel, as you think he was singled out in the class. You reprimand Lindsay for not using proper lighting techniques and thus, placing Marc in this awkward position. You then ask Marc to explain to the other students some of the fundamental aspects of lighting different skin tones.
In this situation, do you think any students were singled out? If so, who, and in what ways?
Would you have asked Marc to explain to others about lighting techniques? Why or why not?
Option C: You thank Lindsay for her work and tell the class it’s an excellent opportunity to talk about lighting techniques. You open up a critical discussion to the class to think about strategies and techniques for future photography assignments.
What worked well in this example? Are there specific inclusive strategies in this option? If so, which?
How could you have anticipated this dialogue differently, if at all?
Would you have followed up with any of the students in this situation? If so, how?
Each semester, you assign a final team project that represents a culmination of the course material and also includes several smaller projects that build upon this final deliverable, a team paper.
Which of the following options for forming teams would you choose?
Thinking further, how might you include opportunities for constructive peer feedback throughout the semester? Would you use this feedback when determining individual grades? Why or why not? As you reflect on this activity, are there any adjustments you may consider making in the future when assigning team work?
Option A: To promote team cohesion, you allow students to pick their own teams.
If you assigned teams, rather than letting the students choose, how might this change the team dynamics? Are there positive aspects to this strategy? Drawbacks?
What are some aspects regarding team work that non-traditional students, such as those with family responsibilities or full-time professionals, face that others do not? Do you think this method supports these students or acts as a barrier to team work?
Option B: You gather information about students at the start of the semester, including: year in school, major of study, interest in the subject matter, and hometown. From their information, you assign diverse student teams.
What are some of the benefits of assigning teams this way? What are some of the challenges teams may confronted in their work?
How might you gauge team dynamics throughout the semester?
What other skills might the students develop while working in diverse teams?
Option C: You randomly assign students to different teams.
Are there benefits to you randomly assigning teams, rather than creating them on yourself? Drawbacks?
If intra-team problems arise, how might you adjust?
What are some skills students can learn from team work, even when there are challenges?
Graduate Student Instructors: Top Tips
If you are a TA who leads labs or discussion sections, or an Assistant Instructor (AI) who is leading your own course, you can use many of these practices for fostering inclusive interactions to build connections with and between your students, and create a positive climate in your own sections/courses! We recognize that a challenge aspect of TAs working with lead professors is the sometimes strange dynamic of being an intermediary between the professor and your students. Here are the two ways you can navigate that terrain in a way that will build your teaching confidence and effectiveness, and benefit your students’ learning.
Go hereDownload here for a more comprehensive list of inclusive teaching strategies for graduate student instructors.
Establish a positive relationship with your lead professor: Ask your professor to clarify your expectations and responsibilities before your first day of class. One way to do this is by asking your professor to complete a “TA Agreement”. Download our suggested TA agreement formLinks to an external site.. In addition, ask if there are opportunities for contributing to the course curriculum, such as conducting a guest lecture, or helping design assessments and rubrics for grading assessments.
Reconsider “authority”: Being in the process of developing expertise and often close in age to your students may create anxiety about how to demonstrate authority in the classroom. That’s not to mention the challenges many of us who have underrepresented social identities face establishing credibility as instructors. But consider challenging the notion that good teaching constitutes establishing authority in the classroom. While you certainly want to have clear expectations for your students that you exercise consistently, think about how you can welcome and empower your students to collaborate in the creation of knowledge by being relatable and sharing aspects of your research that may inspire them. For example, allowing students to work with you to establish ground rules for class discussionLinks to an external site. can help foster student buy-in. And don't be nervous if you don't know an answer to a question they ask or if you make a mistake in front of them: if you are transparent in these moments, you make them "teachable"--you can model for students that learning is a process for all of us.