Rubric

Keep in mind that 90 students have already been assessed using this rubric. Changing it will affect their evaluations.
Exercise 9 - As-Is Process Draft
Exercise 9 - As-Is Process Draft
Criteria Ratings Pts
Is the model clearly titled?
Clearly title/label what is being modeled and that it is as-is.
threshold: pts
10 pts Full Marks
5 pts Partial
0 pts No Marks
pts
10 pts
--
Are actors and entities clearly labeled?
threshold: pts
15 pts Full Marks
8 pts Partial
0 pts No Marks
pts
15 pts
--
Are existing "Systems" clearly depicted and labeled?
These can either be IT systems OR an existing non-IT system (i.e. paper based or manual)
threshold: pts
15 pts Full Marks
8 pts Partial
0 pts No Marks
pts
15 pts
--
Are arrows or connectors clearly used to show interaction of actors/entities/systems/etc?
threshold: pts
15 pts Full Marks
8 pts Partial
0 pts No Marks
pts
15 pts
--
Is model legible and easy to read?
NOTE: The model does not have to be done with Visio or Lucidcharts. Just readable.
threshold: pts
15 pts Full Marks
8 pts Partial
0 pts No Marks
pts
15 pts
--
Are shapes used to depicted parts of the model make sense?
i.e. try to be clear when picking shapes to depict things. For example, if you use a box to depict a user, that may not make sense unless it is clearly labeled. Even if it is labeled, if you use a box to mean many things, you may consider using unique shapes to describe things better.
threshold: pts
15 pts Full Marks
8 pts Partial
0 pts No Marks
pts
15 pts
--
Does it appear that considerable thought and effort went into this?
threshold: pts
10 pts Full Marks
5 pts Partial
0 pts No Marks
pts
10 pts
--
Does the chosen model seem relevant to the project?
Ensure that the model you have chosen is relevant to model/explain the existing client situation. If it does not add much value/explanation to someone who is not familiar with the project, then the type of model is not very relevant.
threshold: pts
5 pts Full Marks
0 pts No Marks
pts
5 pts
--